Here’s a riddle the airlines are hoping you won’t solve. Jet fuel, one of their single biggest costs, just fell about 40% from its spring peak. So your next plane ticket should be cheaper, right?
Wrong. It’s gotten more expensive.
Airfares in May ran nearly 27% higher than a year earlier, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Fuel went down. Fares went up. And the airlines know exactly why — they’re just not eager to say it out loud.
The fuel really did crash — from a war-inflated peak
Let’s start with the part that’s true. Jet fuel really has come down hard.
The Argus U.S. Jet Fuel Index had it around $2.90 a gallon in early July, down roughly 40% from its early-April high. That’s a real drop, and fuel usually eats up 20% to 25% of an airline’s operating costs. So it matters.
But here’s the catch nobody’s putting in the headline. That 40% is a fall from a spike — not a return to normal.
Fuel is still running about 16% higher than it was in late February, before the U.S. and Israel struck Iran and the Strait of Hormuz seized up.
Back in March, I laid out seven ways that same conflict was draining your wallet. The spike was real. The relief is only partial.
So why did your fare go the wrong way?
If fuel is a quarter of the cost, and fuel dropped, basic math says fares should ease. They didn’t. Here’s what’s actually happening.
The airlines aren’t pricing your ticket off their fuel bill. They’re pricing it off you — how many people want to fly, and how many seats they’re willing to sell.
And they’ve done something shrewd on that second part. They cut seats.
Domestic capacity is basically flat versus last year — up a hair at 0.8%, according to OAG Aviation data — while United, American and Delta trimmed 3% to 5% off their schedules. Fewer seats, same summer crowd. You can guess what that does to price.
Then Spirit Airlines shut down in May. There went a big chunk of the cheap-seat supply that used to drag fares down. Fewer discount options, less pressure on the majors to compete.
Quick aside — most internet financial advice comes from people who weren’t alive during the last recession. I’ve been writing about money for more than 35 years. Want rock-solid advice? Sign up for the free Money Talks Newsletter. Takes 10 seconds. No fluff. No spam.
The part they’ll actually admit
Airline executives have basically stopped pretending fuel sets your fare. Ask them, and they’ll point to supply of seats and demand to fly. Not the price of kerosene.
They lost billions when fuel spiked this spring, and now they’d like it back. As long as travelers keep booking at these prices — and many are — there’s no reason for them to blink.
John Gradek, who teaches aviation risk management at McGill University, put the pattern bluntly to Forbes: “Once the airline industry puts fares up, they tend to stay up.”
In short, the fuel excuse got fares up. Your willingness to pay keeps them there.
What this means for your summer
Don’t hold your breath waiting for cheaper fuel to show up in your fare. Experts don’t expect a broad drop before summer ends.
But you’re not powerless. A few moves still work.
Fly at the edges of the season, and lean on the cheapest days to fly — late August and midweek departures tend to run cheaper than the peak weeks. Stay flexible on your dates, because the deals that do surface are short spot sales, not permanent cuts.
And watch the fees, where airlines make a genuine fortune. I’ve broken down the airline tricks that can cost you hundreds — and how to fight back, from carry-on strategy to skipping seat-selection charges.
The bottom line is simple, and a little infuriating. Falling fuel was never going to save you money, because your fare was never really about fuel. It’s about leverage. Right now the airlines have it, and they know it.
So stop waiting for prices to turn fair. Be the nimble, fee-dodging, date-flexible traveler they can’t stand. That’s the only discount you actually control.
Read the full article here
