Close Menu
Fin Street NewsFin Street News
  • Home
  • Business
  • Finance
    • Banking
    • Stocks
    • Commodities & Futures
    • ETFs & Mutual Funds
    • Funds
    • Currencies
    • Crypto
  • Markets
  • Investing
  • Personal Finance
    • Loans
    • Credit Cards
    • Dept Management
    • Retirement
    • Mortgages
    • Saving
    • Taxes
  • Fintech
  • More Articles

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest finance and business news and updates directly to your inbox.

Trending
After 14 years abroad, I moved back to my home state of California. I’m happier now than I’ve been in years.

After 14 years abroad, I moved back to my home state of California. I’m happier now than I’ve been in years.

September 27, 2026
What the Fed’s first rate hike in years means for your wallet

What the Fed’s first rate hike in years means for your wallet

September 27, 2026
I almost said no to my teen’s inconvenient first job. Then I realized how much she needed the experience.

I almost said no to my teen’s inconvenient first job. Then I realized how much she needed the experience.

September 27, 2026
Dario Amodei to have dinner with President Trump in a rare meeting

Dario Amodei to have dinner with President Trump in a rare meeting

September 27, 2026
David Rubenstein shares his recipe for career success — and says boomers like him ‘don’t want to get off the stage’

David Rubenstein shares his recipe for career success — and says boomers like him ‘don’t want to get off the stage’

September 27, 2026
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Press Release
  • Advertise
  • Contact
September 27, 2026 7:08 pm EDT
|
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  Market Data
Fin Street NewsFin Street News
Newsletter Login
  • Home
  • Business
  • Finance
    • Banking
    • Stocks
    • Commodities & Futures
    • ETFs & Mutual Funds
    • Funds
    • Currencies
    • Crypto
  • Markets
  • Investing
  • Personal Finance
    • Loans
    • Credit Cards
    • Dept Management
    • Retirement
    • Mortgages
    • Saving
    • Taxes
  • Fintech
  • More Articles
Fin Street NewsFin Street News
Home » The Red Car Myth and 7 Other Things You Don’t Know About Car Insurance
The Red Car Myth and 7 Other Things You Don’t Know About Car Insurance
Saving

The Red Car Myth and 7 Other Things You Don’t Know About Car Insurance

News RoomBy News RoomSeptember 3, 20264 ViewsNo Comments

You probably know your driving record affects what you pay for car insurance. That makes perfect sense. However, there are other factors at play that are not so obvious.

Join over 10 million drivers who have stopped overpaying by comparing rates with Insurify. It takes minutes to check, and it costs you nothing.

1. Your credit can cost you even with a clean record

In most states, insurers can use your credit history to help set your premium with a credit-based insurance score. This score is calculated from parts of your credit record and is designed to predict insurance losses.

The effect varies by insurer and state, but among the rating factors a company weighs, credit history can change what otherwise similar drivers pay. Some states prohibit the practice, and many others limit how insurers can use the score.

2. A totaled car pays what it is worth, not what you owe

When an insurer declares your car a total loss, it pays the actual cash value, the depreciated market price on the day of the wreck. That is not what you paid, and it is not what you still owe the lender. On a newer financed car, the gap between the two can run thousands of dollars, and it lands on you.

Gap is a separate add-on to the coverage types that actually pay out here, and your insurer can add it. Dealers and lenders may sell their own versions, but those are sometimes debt-waiver agreements rather than insurance, so check what you already carry before you pay for it twice.

3. Filing a claim for minor damage can cost you for years

A small dent you claim can follow your premium long after the repair is done. An at-fault claim can raise your rate, and the surcharge can linger for years, so before you seek payment for minor damage to your own car, weigh the repair against the deductible and the higher premiums that may follow.

Reporting the accident is a separate matter. Your policy may require you to report it even when you decide not to claim, so do not confuse the two. In some states, even a claim that was not your fault can nudge your rate.

4. Driving for Uber can leave you with a coverage gap

A standard personal auto policy generally stops covering you the moment you log in to a rideshare app, and it stays off until the passenger is out and the trip is closed, according to the Insurance Information Institute. The app’s own coverage can leave holes, especially while you are logged in and waiting for a ride.

A rideshare endorsement on your personal policy can close that gap. Delivery apps run under their own rules, so if you drive for one, ask your insurer exactly what applies.

5. Losing a spouse can push your rate up

Marital status is a rating factor in most states, and married drivers tend to pay less than everyone else. The uncomfortable corollary is what happens when a marriage ends. A 2015 Consumer Federation of America comparison found that widowed women paid about 14% more on average across the insurers it tested.

The reasons are statistical, not personal, but the timing is cruel. Some states have pushed back. Delaware now bars insurers from charging an existing customer more solely because their marital status changed after a spouse died.

6. Your job and your diploma can change the price

Some insurers weigh your occupation and education level when setting your rate, on the theory that certain jobs and degrees track with fewer claims. Two drivers with identical records and identical cars can be quoted different prices because of what they do for a living or how far they went in school.

Consumer advocates have long argued these inputs punish people for things unrelated to driving. Several states restrict or ban them, Massachusetts and Michigan among them.

7. The color of your car changes nothing

The red-car premium is folklore. No major insurer prices by paint color, and color does not even appear in your car’s VIN, the identifier they pull to rate the vehicle, according to State Farm.

The myth likely survives because sports cars are often red and cost more to insure for reasons of speed and repair bills, not shade. Buy the color you want.

8. Loyalty does not guarantee you the best price

Renewing with the same insurer does not guarantee the lowest price. Insurers have used techniques known as price optimization to estimate how customers may respond to a rate increase, including how likely they are to shop elsewhere. Regulators have questioned whether pricing on that behavior leaves otherwise similar customers paying different amounts for reasons unrelated to their expected losses, and a number of states have moved to limit it.

The fix is not loyalty. Before you renew, compare quotes using the same coverage and deductibles, since the same driver can draw very different prices from different insurers. Insurers count on you being too busy to shop around, but Insurify has fixed that.

Save $1,100 on your car insurance by comparing real-time quotes side by side without the spam. It’s fast, secure, and rated 4.7 stars on Trustpilot.

Read the full article here

Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Telegram WhatsApp Email

Keep Reading

SNAP Checks Rise Oct. 1, but New Rules May Mean Benefit Cuts Ahead

SNAP Checks Rise Oct. 1, but New Rules May Mean Benefit Cuts Ahead

Flip Out Over These National Pancake Day Deals

Flip Out Over These National Pancake Day Deals

Retailers Are Cracking Down on Returns. These 16 Stores Still Have the Best Policies

Retailers Are Cracking Down on Returns. These 16 Stores Still Have the Best Policies

The RMD Mistake That Costs 401(k) Owners a 25% Penalty

The RMD Mistake That Costs 401(k) Owners a 25% Penalty

8 Reasons Not to Waste Money on Car, Home or Renters Insurance

8 Reasons Not to Waste Money on Car, Home or Renters Insurance

14 Things You Should Throw Out the Day You Retire — Before They Drain Your Savings

14 Things You Should Throw Out the Day You Retire — Before They Drain Your Savings

The Money-Saving Grocery Strategy Hiding in Your Pantry

The Money-Saving Grocery Strategy Hiding in Your Pantry

How to Get the Nike x One Piece Collection in the US

How to Get the Nike x One Piece Collection in the US

McDonald’s Set to Spend Billions on Big Changes: What to Expect

McDonald’s Set to Spend Billions on Big Changes: What to Expect

Add A Comment
Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Editors Picks

What the Fed’s first rate hike in years means for your wallet

What the Fed’s first rate hike in years means for your wallet

September 27, 2026
I almost said no to my teen’s inconvenient first job. Then I realized how much she needed the experience.

I almost said no to my teen’s inconvenient first job. Then I realized how much she needed the experience.

September 27, 2026
Dario Amodei to have dinner with President Trump in a rare meeting

Dario Amodei to have dinner with President Trump in a rare meeting

September 27, 2026
David Rubenstein shares his recipe for career success — and says boomers like him ‘don’t want to get off the stage’

David Rubenstein shares his recipe for career success — and says boomers like him ‘don’t want to get off the stage’

September 27, 2026
5 BI staffers who put AI agents to work share what worked and what went wrong

5 BI staffers who put AI agents to work share what worked and what went wrong

September 27, 2026

Latest News

This small town librarian offers a ‘Bye, Bye AI’ class to take AI off your phone. Now everyone wants in.

This small town librarian offers a ‘Bye, Bye AI’ class to take AI off your phone. Now everyone wants in.

September 27, 2026
Bill Gates says the future of AI will happen in 2 phases and lead to ‘an era of abundance’

Bill Gates says the future of AI will happen in 2 phases and lead to ‘an era of abundance’

September 27, 2026
The startup trap that kept this longevity app founder stuck

The startup trap that kept this longevity app founder stuck

September 27, 2026

Subscribe to News

Get the latest finance and business news and updates directly to your inbox.

Advertisement
Demo
Facebook X (Twitter) Pinterest TikTok Instagram
2026 © Prices.com LLC. All Rights Reserved.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms
  • For Advertisers
  • Contact

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.